Private shelf

Wrapper Score

A rating room for cigar lovers. Handmade cigars are an adult product. In the United States that means 21 and over. Laws differ elsewhere.

Find the best cigars by rating.

Wrapper Score

Highest published scores first. This shelf is a curated humidor of recent Cigar Aficionado classics and Top 25 cigars — not every cigar in the world, and not a personal tasting of each one.

Highest on the shelf
98
My Father The Judge
95+ is Classic on the 100-point scale
How to read this. Scores are Cigar Aficionado’s, from blind tastings, condensed here into short flavor lines. A 95 or above is what the magazine calls Classic. Prices are the list prices printed with those reviews and will have moved. Cuban cigars are included as rated smokes; whether you can buy them depends on the law where you live. Nothing here is medical advice, and nothing here is a recommendation to start smoking.